Human Rights Violations: We publish internal reports on Frontex pushbacks

The EU border police Frontex has been under pressure for months. It is accused of being involved in human rights violations. We publish the internal reports on possible pushbacks that the agency is currently investigating. Frontex wanted to prohibit us from publishing them.

Norwegischer Mittelmeer-Einsatz im Rahmen einer Frontex-Mission –

The EU border police Frontex has observed illegal pushbacks and been involved in others. This is shown by numerous internal reports, so-called Serious Incident Reports, which we publish following a request to Frontex. With the reports, Frontex units reported human rights violations in the Aegean Sea between Greece and Turkey last year. Many of the incidents have been reported before, but the exact accounts are new.

For example, the documents deal with a pushback off the Greek island of Lesvos in April 2020. The Frontex crew of the "Tasty" aircraft reported that the Greek Coast Guard was pulling a boat out of Greek waters and into Turkey, and classified the event as a possible human rights violation.

In another incident in July 2020, Danish helicopter pilots on Frontex deployment reported that the Greek Coast Guard had instructed them to change the coordinates of a boat spotted in Greek waters. Instead, they were to state that the boat had been on the Turkish side of the Aegean Sea. According to the complaint, the Greek operation command said the order was a misunderstanding. However, the Danish forces clearly rejected this.

Publication forbidden

Frontex has forbidden us from publishing the internal reports, citing its alleged copyright on the documents. In order to pass on the information, we would have to ask the authority for permission. We have lodged a complaint against Frontex's behavior with the European Ombudsman and are looking into how we can have Frontex's copyright notices, which we consider illegal, banned by the courts.

Frontex verbietet mit Verweis aufs Urheberrecht die Veröffentlichung seiner Dokumente

The lack of transparency of the EU border police joins a series of cover-ups and lies by Frontex Director Fabrice Leggeri, who made false statements to the European Parliament about human rights violations at the EU's external borders and about connections to arms lobbyists.

In recent weeks, an internal Frontex working group - in which Greece is a member - had investigated the pushback incidents we have now published, but was unable or unwilling to provide a clear explanation, as a report we have also published shows.

Therefore, in addition to the media and civil society organizations, the European Parliament will now have to provide clarification. It has set up a working group that is also to be given access to internal Frontex documents - some of which can already be found in our archive as well as on Statewatch.

to the request

to the Serious Incident Reports

Bild des Autors

Arne Semsrott

Arne ist Journalist und Projektleiter von FragDenStaat.

E-Mail: arne.semsrott@okfn.de (PGP)

Twitter: @arnesemsrott

Unterstützen Sie unsere Arbeit

Wir kämpfen für mehr Transparenz in Politik und Verwaltung!
Machen Sie mit, indem Sie uns spenden! Damit unterstützen Sie unsere Kampagnen, Klagen und Recherchen.

Jetzt spenden

Menschenrechtsverletzungen: Wir veröffentlichen interne Berichte zu Frontex-Pushbacks

Seit Monaten steht die EU-Grenzpolizei Frontex unter Druck. Ihr wird vorgeworfen, in Menschenrechtsverletzungen verwickelt zu sein. Wir veröffentlichen die internen Berichte zu möglichen Pushbacks, die die Behörde derzeit untersucht. Frontex wollte uns die Veröffentlichung verbieten.